Salamalykkum Hasnain and JAMIAHMAD,
First of all i request you both to take positively to your other brother
in islam and respect difference of Openions.
Br Hasnain is also shia ne Ali(a.s) not a enemy. treat him like our
Brother. This issue of akhbariyat and usooli is very old issue and we
all know they have very small difference.
If you see deeply you will find both ask islamic Questions and try to
solve masaels from learned scholars. Then what is wrong and where is the
difference.
Enemies by playing the words like Imam, mujtahid, Try to create dispute
among shia ne Ali(a.s).
Ask the learned Scholars about hadith and masael during ghaibat e imam
mahdi(a.s). We all shia akhbari and usooli know no one can take place or
trying to take place of Imam mahdi(a.s) and he is the Imam who guide all
the learned scholars, if they deserve.
so do not try to create dispute on these small differences. There is no
doubt Marja(the most learned) know thousand time better that us which
hadith is correct which is false and what is the meaning of Verses of
quran and hadith and he issue guide us after going they all Cerses of
quran and hadith e Masumeen(a.s)
Only Imam mahdi(a,s) knows the best and no one akhbari or usooli can
challange thet he is learning directly from Him. If your intention and
neeyat is good and trying to learn from Most learned scholar be sure
Imam mahdi(a.s) will shou you the right path.
ws
--- In shia_strength@
wrote:
>
>
> Imam Khamnae???
>
> You people have given attributes of Aima Masoomeen(asws) to Ulema. and
whosoever oppose you, then the biggest prove you got is fatwa of
Mujtahid.
>
> anyhow we have Hadith e Masoom(asws) and you have mujtahid fatwa.
>
> both things cannot be compared.
>
> I would like to invite you and all people with the same belief to have
a Debate with me regarding using attributes of Imam(asws) with sinful
persons. like Imam, Ruhullah, Ayatullah, Hujjatullah, Wali ul Amr etc.
>
> From previous 1400 years these Attributes or titles were used with
only and only 12 Imams(asws), but now a new ruhullah, a new hujjatullah,
a new wali ul amr and a new Imam is there.
>
>
> salam to all of you.
>
> Regards,
> Hasnain Naqvi
>
>
>
>
No comments:
Post a Comment